|
Recent Articles
Commentary
Dear Mr. Morgenthaler,
Thank you for the “Health & Wellness Update.” I look forward to each issue, and the solid information it provides.
- John V.
Sun City, AZ
Praise for
Smart Publications
Health & Wellness Update
"For sometime now I have enjoyed reading Smart Publications. They are beautifully structured, well written and educational"
- John W.
Durham, NC
"Wealth of information for anyone that chooses alternative healing methods. It's an education in itself just to read one of these newsletters! Every time I get one I read it from cover to cover! Easy to understand and easy to decipher when looking for products. Well done! It's a joy to read."
- B. White
Oxnard, CA
|
All About Natural Testosterone
Full-Text Excerpt of ...
Maximize Your Vitality & Potency
For Men Over 40
By Jonathan V. Wright, M.D. and Lane Lenard, Ph.D.
$14.95 - 256 pages, softcover
[Buy This Book]
Table of Contents
Next section
Chapter 9a
Protecting the Prostate: Natural Alternatives to Proscar®
If a man goes to a physician in the United States with symptoms of benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH), odds are he'll come away with a prescription for the 5-α-reductase inhibiting drug Proscar®. For the reasons discussed in Chapter 8 and in this chapter, Proscar® leaves a lot to be desired as a treatment for BPH, and it may even be dangerous for men at high risk for a certain type of prostate cancer.
Let the same man go to a European physician, and he is far more likely to be offered a natural extract of the dwarf palm serenoa repens, or saw palmetto, sold commercially as Permixon® and Sereprostat®, as well as other natural treatments. In Germany, about 90% of all men diagnosed with BPH are treated with one or more of these natural, botanical agents.1 Numerous well-controlled scientific studies have shown these products to be quite effective for relieving the symptoms of BPH while causing hardly any unwanted effects.
First thing, get a prostate exam
Before beginning any kind of treatment for prostate disease, it is strongly recommended that every man should first have his prostate checked by digital rectal exam and/or a test such as the PSA to rule out the possibility that he might have prostate cancer. This is true even if there are no obvious symptoms of prostate enlargement. If cancer is present, most of the treatments described in this chapter will do little or nothing to slow its progress, but it is not known whether testosterone treatment would exacerbate it or not.
Saw Palmetto: The Multimodal BPH Therapy
Nothing focuses the differences between the pharmaceutical and natural approaches to health care more sharply than the treatment of BPH. Take finasteride (generic name for Proscar®), for example. Designed by computer to fit a particular chemical receptor site, finasteride is a chemical laser-beam aimed at the metabolic juncture where testosterone turns into DHT - the enzyme 5-α-reductase. By inhibiting the action of 5-α-reductase, finasteride drastically reduces the amount of DHT formed in the prostate. This biochemical strategy has achieved a moderate degree of clinical success and a considerable degree of commercial success. More important, perhaps, it has helped pharmaceutical companies propagate the myth - among both the medical and general communities - that excess DHT is the cause of BPH. If you believe this myth, of course, then Proscar® is just what the doctor ordered. Isn't science great!
The problem, as we pointed out in Chapter 8, is that BPH is a lot more complicated than just too much DHT binding too many androgen receptors for too long. Effective treatment requires a strategy that approaches the problem from several different angles. As a complex, naturally occurring substance, you might expect saw palmetto to have a few more therapeutic tricks up its sleeve than a one-trick-pony like finasteride, and you'd be right.
Although saw palmetto extract is used widely in Europe, it is largely rejected by physicians on this side of the Atlantic Ocean. Ironically, it is derived from a plant native to the pine woods and sandy dunes of South Carolina, Louisiana, Georgia, and Florida. Saw palmetto seeds have a long history in Native American medicine as a treatment for irritations of the urinary bladder, urethra, and prostate.2
Exactly how saw palmetto works is not certain. What is certain is that, unlike finasteride, it appears to have a variety of different actions, any or all of which may be beneficial for prostatic health. These actions include an ability to:
- Inhibit 5-α-reductase. Like finasteride, saw palmetto extract can inhibit the action of the enzyme 5-α-reductase, reducing the conversion of testosterone to DHT, but it is thousands of times less potent than finasteride in this regard. The importance of 5-α-reductase inhibition in relieving symptoms of BPH is unclear, however. Some research suggests that reduction of DHT levels seems to occur only at doses of saw palmetto far higher than those typically used to treat BPH.2 Merck, of course, tries to paint finasteride's extremely high potency as a 5-α-reductase inhibitor as an advantage. As we discussed in the previous chapter, though, lots of excellent research disputes this.
- Block DHT binding to prostatic androgen receptors. According to the conventional medical wisdom, the binding of DHT to prostatic androgen receptors is the central event in the proliferation of prostate tissue. Studies show that extract of saw palmetto competes with DHT for androgenic receptors, effectively blocking the binding of DHT.3-6 Saw palmetto's anti-androgenic effects can be substantial. In one experiment, prepubertal rats and mice were castrated to remove the source of endogenous testosterone. The rats then received "testosterone" orally or by injection along with either saw palmetto extract or placebo for six to 12 days. Saw palmetto extract antagonized the prostate-stimulating effects of "testosterone," reducing prostate weight by 46%, compared with placebo.2 Finasteride has never been shown to affect DHT binding. All it can do is keep DHT levels low.
- Reduce prostatic edema (swelling) and inflammation. A too often overlooked clinical element in prostate enlargement is edema and inflammation, a condition called prostatitis. In animal and in vitro (test-tube) studies, saw palmetto extract has been shown to reduce edema and suppress inflammatory mediators.2, 7-9 Finasteride has no effect on prostate inflammation or edema.
- Inhibit the effects of estrogens. As noted in the previous chapter, it is becoming increasingly apparent that the potent estrogen estradiol can be a major stimulant for prostatic cell proliferation. The results of a double-blind, placebo-controlled Italian study have demonstrated that saw palmetto extract blocks estrogen receptors in the prostates of BPH patients, minimizing the growth-stimulating effects of estradiol.10
- Finasteride, of course, does not interfere with the actions of estradiol. In fact, according to Dr. Bruno de Lignieres, by blocking the conversion of testosterone to DHT, finasteride may make more testosterone available for aromatization, thus possibly increasing the amount of estradiol in the prostate. In the long run, this action might theoretically promote excess growth.11
- Antagonize a-adrenergic receptors. Stimulation of a-adrenergic receptors by noradrenaline causes smooth muscle cells all over the body, including the bladder and prostate, to contract.12 Blocking a-adrenoceptors is a therapeutic option for BPH because it can relax these muscles, dilating the urethra slightly, thus permitting a reduction in symptoms. Saw palmetto has recently been shown to block a-adrenergic activity in animal smooth muscle tissue, suggesting yet another avenue by which it may help relieve BPH symptoms.2
Pharmaceutical drugs that block a-adrenergic receptors are sometimes used to treat high blood pressure, and one of those drugs, terazosin, has recently been approved by the FDA for treating BPH also. Others are likely to follow. According to U.S. government statistics, these drugs provide 51% symptomatic improvement for 59 to 86% of users, which is actually superior to finasteride (31% improvement for 54 to 78% of users).13
But a-blockers are awkward to use, in part, because of the difficulty in establishing an effective dose that does not cause unwanted adverse effects (which occur in as many as 43% of users). Also, there is no evidence they provide anything but short-term symptomatic relief. They have no effect on the progression of the disorder, as saw palmetto extract does. Needless to say, finasteride neither blocks a-adrenergic activity nor relaxes prostatic or bladder smooth muscle.
Copyright © 2008 - Smart Publications
POB 4667 - Petaluma, CA 94955
888-998-6889 (fax)
|
Subscribe
to Smart Publications E-newsletter
and receive weekly e-alerts from the world of nutritional medicine.
Just type your email address below and click on submit (unsubscribe anytime.)
Subscribe...to
Smart Publications Health & Wellness Update
the 16-page monthly newsletter.

and receive the latest information from the world of nutritional medicine.
>> subscribe for free!
Advertisement
FREE
Welcome KIt
from Health Freedom Nutrition
Complete product listing and discount offers included!
>> request a kit
|